Grocery
Private Label Reinvents the Spice Aisle
Trader Joe's, Aldi, and HEB are gutting McCormick's grip with hyper-specific blends.
By FTW Editorial·May 20, 2026·5 min read
Private label spice blends — once an afterthought — are systematically dismantling McCormick's category dominance with cuisine-specific, chef-developed SKUs.
What happened
Trader Joe's now stocks 47 private-label seasoning blends, up from 19 in 2022. Aldi launched a 22-SKU Specially Selected spice line in March. HEB's Chairman's Selection blends grew 41% in 2025. McCormick's branded share in the spice category dropped 4.2 points YoY.
Why it matters
Spices are the perfect private-label target: high margin, low brand loyalty, easy quality differentiation. Retailers can now hire former restaurant chefs to develop blends, source single-origin ingredients, and undercut McCormick on price while beating them on quality.
Market impact
Expect McCormick to either acquire a premium private-label spice supplier or push aggressively into branded chef-collab blends. The legacy single-spice business is structurally threatened.
Consumer insight
Consumers no longer believe the branded spice premium is justified. Once they try a Trader Joe's chili-lime or Aldi za'atar at 40% the price, switching is sticky.
Strategic takeaway
If you're a branded spice player, your moat is recipe content and chef partnerships, not the spice itself. Reinvent your marketing model in 2026 or lose another 4 points in 2027.
Get the next signal in your inbox.
Daily food industry intelligence — free.
More signals
Grocery·5 min read
Grocers Are Quietly Pulling Out Self-Checkout
After a decade of build-out, major grocers are removing self-checkout — and the unit economics never worked.
May 20, 2026
Grocery·5 min read
Refrigerated Pet Food Is Building Its Own Grocery Aisle
Fresh pet food crossed 10% category share and is now demanding dedicated refrigerated real estate.
May 20, 2026
Grocery·5 min read
Grocery Pharmacies Are Closing — and Reshaping the Center Store
In-store pharmacy is no longer a traffic driver — and grocers are reclaiming the square footage for fresh and prepared foods.
May 20, 2026